- Levy Library
- Levy Library Guides
- Research Support
- IACUC and Animal Welfare Resources
- Step 3: Keyword Selection
IACUC and Animal Welfare Resources: Step 3: Keyword Selection
Choosing Keywords
Once you have decided what you are searching and where, the next step is to identify keywords. Use your research question, topic or concepts of your protocol to extract relevant keywords that could be useful in the literature search. Here are some things to consider when extracting keywords:
- List relevant keywords for the three R's (3R's)
- Names of diseases or conditions, treatments, or hormones used
- Names of species or model being studied
- Names of drugs, and/or chemicals used
- Synonyms for each keyword term
Below you can find a list of example keywords specific to the three R's (3R's). DO NOT use the word "alternative" as a keyword. Using keywords specific to the three R's will result in a more effective search.
Replacement
Replacement includes the technologies or methods in place to replace or avoid the use of animals
- In vitro
- Software
- Simulation, simulator
- Artificial intelligence
- Cadaver
- Digital imagine
- Cell, cell line, cellular
Reduction
Reduction refers to the strategies used to reduce the number of animals used in research
- Animal model
- Biomarker, biological marker,
- Experimental design
- Reusing, repurposing
- Reduction
- Tissue banks
Refinement
Refinement involves any modifications to the experimental procedure or husbandry practices in an effort to minimize or eliminate pain and distress.
- Anesthesia, anaethesia, anesthetic, anaesthetic
- Analgesic, sedative, tranquilizer
- Animal welfare
- Enrichment
- Non-invasive, minimally invasive, less invasive etc.
- Refinement
Source: Literature Searching: How to Find Animal Use Alternatives, USDA
Subject Headings
A thorough literature review uses both keyword terms and subject headings in the search query. While keywords use natural language to describe a topic, subject headings uses "controlled vocabulary" to describe a topic. Using both will help to refine your search query for precise results. Some things to keep in mind when finding subject headings include the following:
- Not every database has subject headings (EX. Scopus and Web of Science). Use keywords instead.
- Subject headings are unique according to the database (EX. PubMed has MeSH terms and Embase has Emtree terms)
- You will need to modify your subject headings across databases to reflect the differences in vocabulary. For example, if you want to conduct your PubMed search on Embase, you will need to update your MeSH terms for Emtree terms. This is called "translating".
- Make sure the subject headings, just like your keywords are relevant to your topic or research
Below you will find a short list of databases and what terms can be used.
Databases
- PubMed
- Uses MeSH headings and keywords
- Embase (Ovid)
- Uses Emtree terms and keywords
- Web of Science
- Uses keywords
- Scopus
- Uses keywords
- ALTBIB
- Uses MeSH headings and keywords
- USDA National Agricultural Library
- Uses NALT and keywords
Additional Resources
- MeSH DatabaseThe MeSH database is a National Library of Medicine controlled vocabulary thesaurus used for indexing articles in PubMed.
- Learn about Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)A series of tutorials designed to introduce searchers to MeSH terms and how to use it.
- Animal Use Alternatives Thesaurus Terminology (USDA)The USDA thesaurus provides a list in alphabetical order of animal use alternatives.